Showing posts with label Biodiversity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Biodiversity. Show all posts

Monday, 7 November 2016

Human-caused extinctions, values, and religious beliefs

We are currently in the middle of a human-caused extinction crisis (the loss of many species on a Geologically tiny time-scale) that is only projected to get worse over coming decades, as humans continue to homogenize the natural world in order to grow crops, create living spaces, and provide resources for an expanding population.  If you are a religious person, or have some thoughts on how religious people think about this, I'd like to know if you think that religious beliefs either justify these actions or contradict them.  I emphasize some of the Christian perspectives below, but would be particularly interested to hear your point-of-view if you have another faith-background.

In several places in the bible, we are told that all species have intrinsic value (e.g., God created the birds of the sky, fish of the sea, etc... and saw that it was "good").  Yet, the bible also clearly indicates that humans are the 'pinnacle' of creation, and are therefore more important than other species.  It even tells us that we are to "have dominion over them" - which at the very least indicates that we have precedence to displace, if not the priveledge to use and misuse as we please. This is something of a paradox for Christians - some would suggest that, both because because God deemed it to have intrinsic value, and because the diversity of life around us relates directly to our quality of life, it is justifiable to protect that biodiversity from over-exploitation. I think few Christians would argue about the prior argument, but the latter is one that many people disagree with.  As an ecologist, I can say that there is ample evidence for high natural biodiversity having a huge positive impact on human quality of life.  For example, there are well-documented cases of artificially increasing agricultural production through the use of fertilizers, while simultaneously reducing the native microflora and microfauna of the soil, leading to long-term degredation of ecological capacity, including the capacity to produce crops.

From an evolutionary perspective, one could also justify preservation or exploitation: all species evolved from the same elementary life-forms via essentially random processes, and are therefore of equal value, including humans.  We are no more valuable than dogs, gophers, or mushrooms, and therefore do not have the right (whatever that means) to 'play God' and cause these other species to go extinct.  To some extent, this argument ignores that, throughout the geological history of the earth, a small group of highly successful species has often come to dominate ecosystems or even continents, thereby leading to the extinction of many other species.  Indeed, some people have used this justification for the rampant exploitation of natural resources that happens today, suggesting that we are simply following our biologically hard-wired instincts to consume more and increase our genetic inheritance (in theory).  Furthemore, there are clearly different 'levels' of importance (at least ecological importance) for different species - some are simply too rare, too few in number, or too specialized to have much of an impact on the function of the system as a whole.  Although I can assure you that the human species is unique so far in the magnitude of our 'domination', I can't say with certainty that we are or are not following our instincts by causing extinctions, be it from over-use (e.g., passenger pigeons) or from purposeful eradication (e.g., large predators, biting insects).

Now it is clear to most biologists that causing species to go extinct on such a large scale as we currently are is probably not very good for US as a species.  Most of the things we've tried to or successfully gotten rid of have not even been well-understood, and have occasionally caused some pretty serious ripple-effects.  To be sure, there may be some ecological redundancy at larger scales, but most biologists would agree that it's a bad idea to start taking things out and expect that the various ecosystem goods and services will still be available to us later on, particularly given the complexity of these systems. Think of it as playing Jenga while wearing really dark glasses and boxing gloves.

But, despite this view being widely published throughout the scientific literature, and apparently having widespread public support, you don't generally hear priests, reverends, or rhabis telling their congregations to stop eating bluefin tuna or buying new mahogany furniture.  I'm not suggesting they ignore environmental issues - I've heard many preach about responsible consumption, and a couple of years ago the pope actually declared that pollution was a sin - but they seem to ignore that species are being lost at an alarming rate.

Unlike many outspoken scientists, I think religious leaders have great potential to help with the challenges we scientists get to document. But I'm not seeing it yet (at least not at more than a lip-service level), so I'd be grateful if any reading this post could point towards a few examples of local leaders doing so, and perhaps answer a few questions to help me understand all these social and religious complexities.

1) Do you believe that all species have intrinsic value? (in other words, that they have value even if we don't see any particular use for them)
2) Do we have the moral obligation to prevent species from going extinct?
3) How do you justify that belief?
4) If you justify it on religious grounds (even partly), have you ever heard a religious leader speak about it as a problem?

Monday, 13 June 2016

Teaching biodiversity in universities: a question of ethics



Preamble: 

I wrote this as part of an application package when I recently applied for an academic position at a university. I was rather proud of it, so I thought I would share - please enjoy :)

Teaching biodiversity in universities: a question of ethics

Biodiversity is both essential and fanciful – structural and decorative. We depend upon the varieties of life for virtually everything: the air we breathe, the food we eat, the clothes we wear all come from the millions plants, animals, bacteria, and fungi that live around us. The appearances, names, physiological quirks, and natural or cultural history of our native flora, fauna, and fungi can entertain, inspire, stimulate innovation, and call us to action. 

Unfortunately, much of the world's biodiversity is in peril, and particularly for the tiny plants and fungi that form the foundations of our ecosystems, those who know enough to bear witness are few in number. Few non-experts ever experience the joy that comes with recognizing a tree, moss, or mushroom, or even a fruit in the grocery store, as though it were an old friend, let alone noticing its absence. It is a rarity for primary and secondary school curricula to include more than a nod to natural history, despite the widely recognized ability of those same pupils to recite hundreds of names for other things (commercial brands, professional athletes, etc.), and the formative importance of natural science for many of our greatest thinkers today. Obscurity and indifference are threats to biodiversity.  

By teaching the names, the natural history, and the stories that belong to our native (or culturally important) flora, fauna, and fungi, we help our pupils to connect to the land, and to develop a deep sense of responsibility towards it. This connection, and this sense of responsibility, are what  Aldo Leopold termed a "land ethic". For generations, the strongest land ethics were possessed by the professional botanists – the foresters, farmers, and foragers who made their living from plants and fungi – and it was these professionals that became our ethical leaders. We are now on the cusp of a botanical renaissance, one driven by curiosity, creativity, and connectivity. Those of us who are professionals have a responsibility to use this momentum to assist future generations in developing their own land ethic.  

The opportunities for helping students to learn about biodiversity have never been more promising. From plant-recognition applications and citizen science projects, to popular science blogs, books, and documentary films, our students are awash in inspiration. The applications of biodiversity have never been more creative: from bio-engineering solutions to wastewater treatment, to using fungal mycelia as replacements for Styrofoam packaging, no student should feel a lack of entrepreneurial opportunities from botany or mycology. Combined with traditional resources, such as museum collections and constantly expanding literature databases, we also have a plethora of opportunities for students to contribute to scientific content in concrete ways. Inspiration, information, entrepreneurial potential, and concrete opportunities to contribute are what our students crave, and what they will receive from studying biodiversity.

Those who teach at universities bear a special responsibility to our communities and the natural world, because we do more than teach the future biologists – we teach politicians, lawyers, physicians, engineers, and perhaps most importantly, we teach the future teachers. As biodiversity experts, our ability to influence society for the better is magnified many times over when we teach. To truly engage students, we must allow them to contribute. If we encourage their curiosity with simple tools, embrace their creativity through applied tasks, and celebrate their connectivity by asking them to share, their scientific skills and passion for biodiversity will grow alongside their land ethic – the few will become the many. Just as our understanding of one another is fostered by knowing each others' personal stories, a land ethic is fostered by learning the stories of the flora, fauna, and fungi around us.